NYSDA Publications

AHRQ Issues CDSiC Newsletter

Aug 21, 2024

The Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality (AHRQ) has issued its Clinical Decision Support Innovation Collaborative (CDSiC) newsletter.

Issue Number 21 | August 21, 2024
In this edition of the Insider, we highlight three new AHRQ CDSiC-developed resources focused on cutting-edge patient-centered clinical decision support (PC CDS) topics, including leveraging artificial intelligence (AI), analyzing override reasons, and prioritizing areas for measurement, as well as a PC CDS-focused funding opportunity from AHRQ.
Table of Contents:
While AI has been used with CDS to improve healthcare delivery, there has not yet been an exploration of opportunities, considerations, and recommendations for the use of AI to scale PC CDS and overcome implementation barriers. To fill this gap, the AHRQ CDSiC Implementation, Adoption, and Scaling Workgroup developed a report that provides an overview of current approaches for using AI to scale PC CDS, outlines existing challenges, and documents opportunities to advance this important area.

The report identifies five dimensions of PC CDS to which AI can be applied to facilitate scaling: 1) automate processes, 2) facilitate technical development and support of PC CDS, 3) complement direct/immediate clinician interaction, 4) support cognitive processes and decision making, and 5) facilitate sharing and replication of PC CDS. The findings in this report will enable PC CDS stakeholders to better understand and leverage AI to scale PC CDS more widely and encourage the use of AI in PC CDS among clinicians, patients, and their care teams. Read the report here!
Recipients of PC CDS alerts and recommendations may choose not to follow the guidance for various reasons. Some CDS systems require recipients to identify a reason when they choose not to follow the guidance, called an "override reason," which can provide insight into ways CDS can be improved. Recognizing the value of this information to CDS researchers and developers, the AHRQ CDSiC Standards and Regulatory Frameworks Workgroup created an initial taxonomy of override reasons composed of reasons that may be selected by patients, caregivers, clinicians, or other recipients of PC CDS.

The taxonomy serves as a foundation for analysis, providing a shared set of domains and subdomains that capture a broad range of potential override reasons. It supports PC CDS developers and researchers when analyzing why users do not accept PC CDS guidance, and is especially useful for facilitating comparison of overrides of PC CDS across different institutions to share lessons learned.
Outcome measurement is key to determining if PC CDS is achieving its goals. Since PC CDS is intended to support patients' decision making, measurement should assess if CDS influences outcomes that are important to patients. To support this goal, the AHRQ CDSiC Measurement and Outcomes Workgroup elicited feedback from patients and patient advocates on which patient health journey measures should be prioritized when assessing PC CDS. These important findings, and critical areas for future work, are available in a new AHRQ CDSiC report.

PC CDS researchers and implementers, as well as healthcare organizations, can use this report to inform which patient-centered measurement areas should be included in PC CDS assessments.




Read the report by clicking below!



 
Implementing and Evaluating PC CDS Strategies in Real-World Settings (U18) 

AHRQ recently published a Notice of Funding Opportunity (NOFO) titled Implementing and Evaluating PC CDS Strategies in Real-World Settings RFA-HS-24-003 (U18). Applicants will propose innovative collaborative research to understand how CDS tools in real-world healthcare settings can be improved to become more patient-centered. Funded research will contribute to generalizable knowledge about how patients, families, and caregivers can become meaningful partners in the codesign, implementation, use, and evaluation of PC CDS.

Since 2016, AHRQ's Patient-Centered Outcomes Research (PCOR) CDS Initiative, and the CDSiC in particular, have developed resources that are now publicly available for investigator-initiated research to further develop, test, and build upon in real-world healthcare settings. Using these resources as starting materials, applicants will propose innovative collaborative research to understand how CDS tools in real-world healthcare settings can be improved to become more patient-centered. Read more about this exciting opportunity on AHRQ's funding page here

Applications for this opportunity are due on September 12, 2024.
The 2024 MCBK Global Meeting will take place virtually on October 23, 2024. The meeting will focus on exploring generative AI, including the role generative AI can play in improving human health by mobilizing computable knowledge around the world.
 
Find out more – and register for free – at the MCBK website.
All 20 past issues of the Insider are now available on our website! Click here to view our past issues, which share more about the AHRQ CDSiC products that have been produced so far and important resources for PC CDS stakeholders.
This section highlights two recently published journal articles that feature topics of interest to CDSiC stakeholders. These articles further the PC CDS research agenda with their cutting-edge contributions to several topics, including:
  • The documentation and classification of CDS malfunctions.
  • The co-design of patient care tools and the visualization of patient-reported outcome (PRO) data in support of shared decision making, critical areas that the CDSiC has also explored in its work.
Journal of the American Medical Informatics Association
A Scoping Review of Rule-Based Clinical Decision Support Malfunctions
This scoping review captured 130 CDS malfunctions, which were then coded according to an existing taxonomy. The review revealed the limited amount of literature documenting CDS malfunctions, and the ongoing need for existing taxonomies of CDS malfunctions to be updated.
jcm-logo
Implementation of a Co-Design Strategy to Develop a Dashboard to Support Shared Decision Making in Advanced Cancer and Chronic Kidney Disease
This article describes the process of patients, care partners, and clinicians codesigning a data visualization dashboard. The dashboard aimed to provide both clinicians and patients with timely, easily understandable information on the patient's health and preferences to support shared decision making, and was informed by PRO data. An evaluation of the codesign process revealed that it was successfully implemented.
Patient and Caregiver Perspectives on Generative Artificial Intelligence in Patient-Centered Clinical Decision Support

Developed by the AHRQ CDSiC Trust and Patient-Centeredness Workgroup, this report describes patient and caregiver perspectives on the use of generative AI in PC CDS, factors that impact trust in AI technology, and AI's impact on trust and the patient-clinician relationship, while providing specific considerations for the development and implementation of AI-supported PC CDS tools.
Inventory of Patient Preference Measurement Tools for PC CDS Report

Developed by the AHRQ CDSiC Measurement and Outcomes Workgroup, this inventory report describes an inventory that identifies specific patient preference measurement tools used in clinical settings and describes considerations and challenges to adopting and using patient preference measurement tools in practice. The accompanying filterable and sortable inventory spreadsheet provides details on the delivery method, context, and validity of each tool.
 
The Clinical Decision Support Innovation Collaborative (CDSiC) is a community of broad, diverse stakeholders at the forefront of using technology to better support care teams, patients, and caregivers. The CDSiC is working toward healthcare decisions that are driven by both patient-centered and patient-specific information and that align with patient needs, preferences, and values. The CDSiC is funded by the Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality (AHRQ) as part of a multi-component initiative to help advance patient-centered outcomes research into practice through CDS. For any inquiries regarding the CDSiC you may contact the project team at CDSiC@norc.org.